
What Should Have Been A Straightforward Battle Result Has Instead Sparked A Heated Debate Over Whether The Coach Got It Completely Wrong.
·15/10/2026·Comments off
The Voice fans are divided after Riley Green chose Keiyana Osmond over Brendan Coulter following their Battle Round performance of Maroon 5’s “She Will Be Loved.” Although both singers impressed the coaches with their take on Adam Levine’s hit, many viewers believe Coulter deserved to advance, with some calling the decision a major mistake and questioning why no other coach stepped in to save him.

Green paired Coulter and Osmond for the Maroon 5 classic during the Season 30 Battles, giving the two Team Riley artists a chance to show off their vocal styles with a song outside the usual country repertoire.
During rehearsals, Green admitted he was excited to hear their version because the song was one he would never be able to sing. He even joked about Levine’s facial hair, saying, “It’s a tradeoff. You either get to grow a great mustache or you get to sing this song. I chose earlier.”
Coulter was particularly comfortable with the song, revealing that “She Will Be Loved” was the first song he ever sang. Green praised his falsetto, while Battle Advisor Carly Pearce complimented Osmond’s tone and distinctive style. Green described them as “two of the most talented people on the show.”
Their performance also earned a reaction from Levine, who wrote the hit with Maroon 5 and was clearly pleased to hear the contestants perform it.
“Excellent song choice, Riley,” Levine said, thanking the singers for bringing the song to the stage. He also reminded them how demanding the track could be, praising both for doing a great job.

“I don’t want to pick anybody that’s singing my song. I’ll let him pick, because that’ll be more fun to watch him suffer,” Levine joked, leaving the final decision to Green.
Despite the praise, Green had to choose only one singer to move forward. He acknowledged how proud he was of both contestants and specifically praised Coulter for his performance. However, Green ultimately selected Osmond, explaining that her interesting style helped her stand out.
The decision quickly sparked debate among viewers, many of whom felt Coulter had delivered the stronger performance.
“Brendan clearly won that battle! He was robbed!” one fan wrote.

Another viewer shared their surprise at the outcome, commenting, “When Brenden sang, I thought ‘this person could win the whole show’!!! And then whaaaat???? And then, no steal?? ”
Others questioned whether Green had made the right call. “Riley!! You sent the wrong one home!” one commenter declared, while another wrote, “Brendan was clearly the winner of this competition.”
Several fans also appeared to expect another coach to use a steal on Coulter, making his elimination even harder for them to accept.
“I thought someone would steal Brendan! I like both!” one viewer commented.
Another fan said, “Ooo he definitely counted on someone stealing… because Brendan did better in this case ”
Not everyone agreed with the criticism, however. Some viewers praised Osmond’s performance and supported Green’s decision, while others felt both singers had done well but that Coulter stood out more in this particular Battle.
One fan offered a more balanced take, writing, “Brendan did so well!! Keiyana sang beautifully and is clearly very talented, but in this battle, she…”
The debate continued as viewers shared their disappointment over Coulter’s elimination, with several insisting that his voice had the potential to carry him far in the competition.
Although Green ultimately chose Osmond, the reaction showed just how strongly many viewers connected with Coulter’s performance. With no steal coming to his rescue, his journey on The Voice came to an end, leaving fans questioning whether the coach had made the right decision.